Self-Locking Screw Efficiency: Less Than 50% Effective?

The efficiency of a self-locking screw is a topic in mechanical engineering that explores the relationship between the screw's design and its ability to secure objects effectively. This efficiency is a critical factor in determining the screw's performance and safety. When considering the efficiency of a self-locking screw, it is important to note that it should not exceed 50%. If the efficiency surpasses this threshold, the screw is considered to be in a state of overhauling, which can lead to potential issues. Understanding the factors that influence the efficiency of self-locking screws is crucial for engineers and designers to ensure the safe and proper use of these fasteners.

Self-locking screws require a positive torque to be applied to lower the load

Self-locking screws are a type of power screw, also known as a lead screw, that can be used to generate very large forces. By holding the nut stationary and rotating the shaft, the nut can be made to slide up or down the shaft. This allows a relatively small moment on the shaft to create a much larger force on the nut.

The efficiency of a self-locking screw is always less than 50%. If the efficiency is more than 50%, the condition is known as overhauling. For a self-locking screw, the coefficient of friction is equal to or greater than the tangent of the helix angle.

The torque required to lower the load on a self-locking screw can be calculated using the following formula:

> ${M_t} = \frac{{W{d_m}}}{2}\tan \left( {ϕ - α } \right)$

Where:

• $M_t$ = torque required to lower the load
• W = load on the screw (in N)
• $d_m$ = mean diameter of the screw (in m)
• $ϕ$ = friction angle
• $α$ = helix angle

When $ϕ ≥ α$, the formula $\tan \left( {ϕ - α } \right) ≥ 0$ holds true, meaning that $Mt ≥ 0$. In other words, a positive torque is required to lower the load. This means that the load will not turn the screw and will not descend unless force is applied.

In this case, the screw is known as a 'self-locking screw' and will hold its position without the need for a brake.

If efficiency is greater than 50%, the screw is overhauling

The efficiency of a self-locking power screw should be 50% or less for effective self-locking. If the efficiency is greater than 50%, the screw is considered to be overhauling. This means that the load will turn the screw and descend on its own unless a restoring torque is applied to hold the load.

In a self-locking screw, the coefficient of friction is equal to or greater than the tangent of the helix angle. The helix angle is the angle between the direction of the force applied to the screw and the axis of the screw. The friction angle is the angle between the force of friction and the normal force.

The efficiency of a screw can be calculated using the following formula:

> Efficiency = Ideal effort / Actual effort = tan(α) / tan(α + φ)

Where:

• Α is the lead angle
• Φ is the angle of friction

For a self-locking screw to function effectively, it is essential that the helix angle is smaller than the friction angle. This ensures that the coefficient of friction is greater than the tangent of the helix angle, which is necessary for self-locking.

If the efficiency of a self-locking screw is greater than 50%, it means that the screw is not effectively self-locking. In this case, the screw will require a negative torque to lower the load. This means that the load will turn down the screw and descend on its own unless a restoring torque is applied to prevent it. This condition, where the efficiency is greater than 50%, is known as overhauling.

The coefficient of friction is equal to or greater than the tangent of the helix angle

Self-locking screws are used in applications where vibration may cause the fastener to loosen. These screws have a feature that prevents them from coming loose due to vibrations or other forces. The mechanism that makes a screw self-locking is the difference between the helix angle of the screw and the coefficient of friction between the screw and the mating surface.

The coefficient of friction is a value that represents the resistance of one surface to sliding over another. It is calculated by dividing the force required to move one surface over another by the weight of the object. The coefficient of friction is a dimensionless number that ranges from 0 to 1.

The helix angle of a screw is the angle between the screw's axis and the line of its threads. It is measured in degrees or radians. The helix angle determines the screw's lead, which is the distance that the screw advances axially in one complete revolution.

For a self-locking screw, the coefficient of friction is equal to or greater than the tangent of the helix angle. This relationship is described by the formula:

Mt = Wdm/2 tan (ϕ−α)

Where:

• Mt = torque required to lower the load
• W = load on the screw in N
• Dm = mean diameter of the screw in m
• Φ = friction angle
• Α = helix angle

When ϕ ≥ α, the resulting torque is positive, meaning that a force is required to lower the load. In this case, the screw will not descend on its own unless an external effort is applied. Such screws are known as self-locking screws.

When ϕ < α, the resulting torque is negative, meaning that the load will cause the screw to turn and descend on its own unless a restoring torque is applied. This situation is known as 'overhauling of the screw' or back drawing of the screw.

Therefore, for a self-locking screw to function properly, the coefficient of friction must be equal to or greater than the tangent of the helix angle. This ensures that the screw remains in place and does not loosen due to vibrations or other forces.

The efficiency of a self-locking square threaded power screw is less than 50%

The efficiency of a self-locking square threaded power screw is an important consideration in mechanical engineering. Power screws, also known as lead screws, are used to convert rotary motion into linear movement, and are often used in applications such as screw jacks and production machines. The efficiency of a screw is defined as the work output over the work input.

For a self-locking screw, the maximum efficiency is 50%. If the efficiency exceeds 50%, the condition is known as overhauling. The efficiency of a square threaded screw is calculated using the formula:

> $\eta=\frac{tan\alpha}{tan(\phi+\alpha} \)$

Substituting the limiting value for $\phi=\alpha$ gives:

> $\eta \leq\ \frac{tan\alpha}{tan(\phi+\phi}\)$

> $\eta \leq\ \frac{tan\alpha}{tan2 \phi}$

> $tan2 \phi= \frac{2tan\phi}{1-tan^2\phi}$

> $\eta \leq\ \frac{tan\phi(1-tan^2\phi)}{2tan\phi}$

> $\eta \leq\ [\frac{1}{2}-\frac{tan^2{\phi}}{2}]$

Therefore, the efficiency of a self-locking square threaded power screw is less than 50%.

This is a useful property as it means that a self-locking power screw will hold its position and load unless a torque is applied. For example, most screw jacks for cars are self-locking and will not run down when the handle is released.

However, the disadvantage of power screws is that they have relatively low efficiency, and one way to improve this is by reducing friction, for example by using ball screws.

Efficiency is calculated as ideal effort divided by actual effort

Efficiency is a measure of performance that uses the least amount of input to achieve the highest amount of output. It is calculated as the ratio of useful output to total input, or mathematically, as output divided by input.

Efficiency is often associated with effectiveness, but they are distinct concepts. Effectiveness is the ability to achieve a desired result, which can be expressed quantitatively but does not require complicated mathematics. Efficiency, on the other hand, is typically calculated as a percentage of the ideal result, for example, if no energy was lost due to friction, 100% of the fuel would be used to produce the desired result.

In the context of self-locking screws, efficiency is calculated as ideal effort divided by actual effort. The efficiency of a square threaded screw can be calculated using the formula:

\[ \eta = \frac{tan\alpha}{tan(\phi + \alpha)} \]

Where:

• \(\eta\) is efficiency
• \(\alpha\) is the helix angle
• \(\phi\) is the friction angle

For a self-locking screw, the coefficient of friction is equal to or greater than the tangent of the helix angle (\(\phi \geq \alpha\)). Substituting this condition into the formula, we get:

\[ \eta \leq \frac{tan\alpha}{tan(\phi + \phi)} \]

Further simplification yields:

\[ \eta \leq \frac{1}{2} - \frac{tan^2\phi}{2} \]

This shows that the efficiency of a self-locking square threaded power screw is always less than 1/2, or 50%.

The maximum efficiency of a self-locking screw is 50%. If the efficiency exceeds 50%, it is no longer considered self-locking and is referred to as overhauling.

Frequently asked questions